Defunding Rail Maintenance: Keeping Today’s Trains Alive for Tomorrow’s Riders

on

One Metro Manila line still runs cars that first carried passengers in December 1999, nearly 27 years ago (DOTr, 1999). At rush hour, many carry more people than they were designed for. By night, crews have a few hours to get them ready again.

That nightly work is maintenance: the brake part changed before it wears through and the air-conditioning unit serviced before the hot months. Skipped, it shows up on the platform.

Passengers and officials have asked for longer operating hours. The wish is fair, but every added hour of service comes out of the night crews need to keep the trains safe and comfortable. The transportation department has said permanently longer hours would compromise that work (DOTr, GMA News, Dec. 12, 2024).

The Philippines does not build its own trains, and most of their critical components are imported. When an order slips, the rehabilitation slips with it, and the train sits in the depot while the platform fills. Steady maintenance prevents many of the failures commuters dread: sudden stops in operations, unloadings, dead air-conditioning and signaling faults after an upgrade. It also keeps waits between trains predictable. Let maintenance slide on an aging system and the risk of failure climbs every month, until the only question left is which morning.

“Let maintenance slide on an aging system and the risk of failure climbs every month, until the only question left is which morning.”

For some of our oldest trains, the maintenance manuals point to the end of their service life, partly because many original parts are no longer produced. Filipino engineers and technicians have refused to accept that. They keep finding ways to repair what the book treats as beyond repair, and many of those trains still carry passengers.

Riders know these scenes, even when no report records them. Siksikan sa loob ng tren, mahabang pila sa platform, a coach without cooling at noon, or a stalled train whose passengers walk the track to the next station.

The damage does not stay in one train. When parts run short, crews may take them from one train to keep another moving. Past a certain point, restoring a stripped train can cost more than it is worth, and it may be retired for good. Then the line can lose it permanently, along with the seats future commuters were counting on.

The record shows the way back. In 2016, trains on that same line unloaded passengers 586 times (COA audit report, Inquirer, July 2, 2017). Aging equipment and delayed spare-parts procurement had cut the cars in service, the original contractor said (press release, May 31, 2023). Rehabilitated and properly maintained, the same line recorded zero unloading incidents in 2021 (DOTr, Top Gear Philippines, June 8, 2022).

That work needs steady money, because new trains take years to arrive and the old ones are all we have until then. For one state railway, that money has already thinned. Its maintenance program shrank by about 90 percent between 2023 and 2025, while its administration budget fell by about a tenth (DBM, 2023 and 2025 GAAs). Part of the cut followed the closure of its Metro Manila service in March 2024 (Inquirer, March 2024), but trains still running, and those parked, still need care. The 2026 budget restored almost none of it (DBM, 2026 GAA).

Recovery starts with treating maintenance as a fixed cost of running a railway, sized to each fleet’s engineering schedule and protected from transfer. Long-lead and obsolete parts should be bought ahead under multi-year contracts, so one late order no longer grounds a train.

The next administration will inherit these trains as we leave them. A well-kept old train can still carry a worker home tonight.

Ang piyesang hindi binili ngayong taon, pasahero ang magbabayad sa susunod.

 

Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and are intended to encourage public discussion on governance and national issues. They do not represent any official position of the institutions the author may be affiliated with.

About the Author: Paul Y. Chua, PhD, is an electronics and communications engineering graduate of De La Salle University. He holds doctoral degrees in Fiscal Management and Peace and Security, and a master’s degree in National Security Administration. He has completed executive programs in several countries, specializing in transport, migration, urban planning, and public policy, with emphasis on governance, innovation, and integrity.


Discover more from CurrentPh News

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

LEAVE A REPLY

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

MUST READ

THERE IS NO PEACE IN PAX SILICA: The American...

Pax Silica promises economic security. But whose security? It speaks of technological progress, supply-chain resilience and strategic cooperation. What it does not promise is...

High food prices, corruption dominate Filipinos’ online concerns —...

MANILA, Philippines— Rising food prices, demands for higher wages, and allegations of corruption involving government flood-control projects dominate online discussions nationwide, according to Matanaw...

Tiu-Laurel, may koneksyon sa isang rice importer?

Sinisilip ang posibleng conflict of interest ni Department of Agriculture (DA) Secretary Francisco Tiu Laurel Jr. matapos lumutang ang kanyang corporate connection sa Planters...

SC Petition: Recovery of Hidden Wealth and Suspension of...

SC Petition: Recovery of hidden wealth and suspension of Impeachment Trial The Partido Maharlika has joined concerned Filipino citizens Mario P. Pagaragan, Jr. and...

METRO Backs DOTR Sec Dizon’s Reforms, seeks protection for...

MANILA, Philippines— Motorcycle taxi riders' group METRO has thrown its support behind Transportation Secretary Vince Dizon's efforts to address regulatory issues in the motorcycle...

Discover more from CurrentPh News

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading